A US judge has ruled that Google acted illegally to crush its competition and maintain a monopoly on online search and related advertising. The landmark decision on Monday is a major blow to Alphabet, Google’s parent company, and could reshape how technology giants do business.
Google was sued by the US Department of Justice in 2020 over its control of about 90% of the online search market. It is one of several lawsuits filed against big tech companies as US antitrust authorities attempt to strengthen competition in the industry.
This case has been described as posing an existential threat to Google and its owner given its dominance in the search and online advertising business. It is unclear yet what penalties Google and Alphabet will face as a result of the decision. Fines or other remedies will be decided in a future hearing. The government has asked for “structural relief,” which could, in theory, mean the break-up of the company.
In his decision, US District Judge Amit Mehta said Google had paid billions to ensure it is the default search engine on smartphones and browsers. “Google is a monopolist, and it has acted as one to maintain its monopoly,” Judge Mehta wrote in his 277-page opinion.
Alphabet said it plans to appeal against the ruling. “This decision recognises that Google offers the best search engine, but concludes that we shouldn’t be allowed to make it easily available,” the company said in a statement.
US Attorney General Merrick Garland hailed the ruling as a “historic win for the American people.” “No company—no matter how large or influential—is above the law,” Garland said. “The Justice Department will continue to vigorously enforce our antitrust laws.”
Federal antitrust regulators have filed other pending lawsuits against Big Tech companies—including Meta Platforms, which owns Facebook, Amazon, and Apple Inc.—accusing them of operating unlawful monopolies.
Monday’s ruling follows a 10-week trial in Washington DC, in which prosecutors accused Google of spending billions of dollars annually to Apple, Samsung, Mozilla, and others to be pre-installed as the default search engine across platforms. The US said Google typically pays more than $10bn a year for that privilege, securing its access to a steady stream of user data that helped maintain its market hold. This, prosecutors argued, prevented other companies from having the opportunity or resources to meaningfully compete.
“The best testimony for that, for the importance of defaults, is Google’s chequebook,” argued Department of Justice lawyer Kenneth Dintzer during the trial.
Google’s search engine is a significant revenue generator, bringing in billions of dollars largely due to advertising displayed on its results pages. Google’s lawyers defended the company by saying that users are attracted to their search engine because they find it useful and that Google is investing to make it better for consumers. “Google is winning because it’s better,” said Google’s lawyer John Schmidtlein during closing arguments.
Schmidtlein also argued that Google faces intense competition not just from general search engine firms, such as Microsoft’s Bing, but also from more specialised sites and apps that people use to find restaurants, airline flights, and more. In his ruling, Judge Mehta concluded that being the default search engine is “extremely valuable real estate” for Google. “Even if a new entrant were positioned from a quality standpoint to bid for the default when an agreement expires, such a firm could compete only if it were prepared to pay partners upwards of billions of dollars in revenue share,” Judge Mehta wrote.
Another case against the technology company over its advertising technology is scheduled to go to trial in September. In Europe, meanwhile, Google has been fined billions in monopoly cases.
Melissa Enoch
Follow us on:
Former US President Donald Trump on Saturday declined a second debate with Vice President Kamala…
Munich's Mayor Dieter Reiter has officially opened Oktoberfest at noon Saturday by tapping the first…
Daniel Dubois scored an upset victory and ruined Anthony Joshua's return to London's Wembley Stadium…
Elon Musk’s social media platform, X, has named Rachel de Oliveira Conceicao as its legal…
In a surprising turn during the Edo state governorship election, Olumide Akpata, the Labour Party…
The Governor of Ondo state, Mr. Lucky Aiyedatiwa, has vowed to transform the state into…
View Comments
GREETINGS! GREETINGS!! GREETINGS!!!
MERCEDES BENZ.ML350=#1.9MILLION..
MERCEDES BENZ =ML550.#3.2MILLIO.
Toyota Land Cruiser-N2.5 million
• Toyota Prado N2 million
• Toyota Corolla –N750,000-1.9m
• Toyota Camry –N550,000-N1.8 M
• Toyota Avensis – N950,000-N1.7M
• Toyota Yaris – N900,000
• Toyota Venza – N2.8 million
TOYOTA HIGH LANDER ₦2.2MILLION
GOLF 2 ₦25O,000.
GOLF 3 ₦350,000.
GOLF 4 ₦500,000.
AND MANY MORE
Toyota RAV4 SUV –N1.2milli
• Toyota Hilus Pickup-N950,000
• Toyota Dyna Truck – N1.3million
• Toyota Hiace Bus – N1.5 million
* Toyota Highlander-N1.2 million
*Toyota Big daddy-N850,000-1.9 m
AUCTIONING OF BAGS OF RICE AND GALLONS OF OIL AT CHEAP AND AFFORDABLE PRICES.
➡GALLONS OF OIL =13,000
👇👇👇
#RICE
▪PER BAGS OF RICE ARE:-
➡RISING SUN= N10,500
➡SECIAL RICE= N10,500
➡MAMA AFRICA= 10,500
➡TOMATO RICE= N10,500
➡CAPRICE = N10,500.
AND MANY MORE EXCLUSIVE OFFER'S.
ADDRESS. NO.110 IDIROKO CUSTOM AREA COMMAND IN OGUN STATE BORDER..
CONTACT THE ASST STATE AUCTIONEER.
NUMBER:-[O8O__6739__9O9O]
FOR ANY FURTHER INFORMATION..
Bags of Rice === #18, 500 Per Bag
Groundnut Oil 25litres === #12, 00 Per Gallon...
WE DELIVER TO ANY STATE IN NIGERIA PER BAG IS N1000 FOR DELIVERY. THANK YOU