The US Court of Appeals in Washington, DC, has rejected Nigeria’s claim to sovereign immunity in a legal battle over a $70 million arbitration award won by Zhongshan Fucheng Industrial Investment Co. Ltd., a Chinese firm involved in developing a free trade zone in Ogun State, Nigeria. On August 9, 2024, the court upheld a lower court ruling that the arbitration award is enforceable under the New York Convention, stripping Nigeria of its sovereign immunity in this case. This decision is the latest in a series of legal setbacks for Nigeria, which has also faced similar rulings in the UK and France.
The dispute began with a 2010 agreement where Zhongshan acquired rights to develop the Ogun Free Trade Zone. However, the relationship between Zhongshan and the Ogun State government deteriorated in 2016, leading to an arbitration case. The arbitrators found that Nigeria breached its obligations under the bilateral investment treaty with China, awarding Zhongshan $70 million in compensation. Despite Nigeria’s efforts to contest the ruling, the US court’s decision marks a significant victory for the Chinese firm.
Following this legal defeat, the situation escalated further when, in March and August 2024, the Judicial Court of Paris issued ex parte orders for the seizure of three Nigerian presidential aircraft undergoing routine maintenance in France and Switzerland. These orders were part of Zhongshan’s efforts to enforce the arbitration award. The aircraft, including a newly acquired Airbus A330, were seized despite Nigerian government objections that they were sovereign assets protected by diplomatic immunity.
Earlier on Thursday, Nigeria announced that it has initiated both legal and diplomatic measures to secure the release of the seized aircraft, arguing that the dispute involved only the Ogun State government and should not affect federal assets. The Nigerian government accused Zhongshan of misleading the Paris court and emphasised that the aircraft were immune from attachment due to their status as sovereign assets used exclusively for government purposes. Despite these efforts, Zhongshan remains confident in the arbitral panel’s decision, which has been upheld by courts in multiple countries.
The Nigerian government continues to resist the enforcement of the arbitration award, maintaining that the seizure of its assets is inappropriate and unlawful. However, Zhongshan has expressed a willingness to engage in negotiations with the Nigerian government to resolve the matter amicably, while also standing firm in its right to enforce the arbitral award under international law.
NNEOMA UDENSI
Follow us on:
The Rural Electrification Agency (REA) under its Energising Education Programme (EEP), on Friday, signed agreements…
Justice Peter Lifu of a Federal High Court in Abuja, on Friday, dismissed a suit…
The Statistician-General/Chief Executive, National Bureau of Statistics (NBS), Mr. Semiu Adeniran, on Friday disclosed that…
The 2,249,780 voters in Edo State that have collected their Permanent Voters Cards (PVCs) out…
President Bola Tinubu on Friday declared that his purpose for seeking the nation's number one…
Kano state government is partnering Tony Blair Institute for Global Change to attract $23.5 million…
View Comments
IMPORTEDED VEHICLES & DIFFERENT TYPES OF GENERATORS, AUCTION PHONE'S. FOR SALE AT CHEAP AND AFFORDABLE AUCTION PRICE INTERESTED BUYER SHOULD KINDLY CONTACT US ON O8O__6739__9O9O.
BAGS OF RICE AND VEGETABLE OIL FOR SALE IN A CHEAP AND AFFORDABLE PRICE, BUYER SHOULD CONTACT US ON O8O__6739__9O9O.
ARE ALSO AVAILABLE FOR SALES.
SOME OF THE AVAILABLE VEHICLES AND THEIR AUCTION PRICES ARE:
Toyota 4Runner #950,000
Toyota Avalon #900,000
Toyota Avensis #950,000
Toyota Camry tiny light #450,000
Toyota Camry muscle #850,000.
Toyota Camry Big daddy #650,000
Toyota Corolla le #500,000/#850,000. Corolla S, XLE
Toyota FJ Cruiser #1.1M
Toyota Hiace #1.5m
Toyota Highlander #950,000
Toyota Hilux #1.2m
Toyota Matrix #600,000
Toyota Prado #2m
Toyota Rav4 #650,000
Toyota Sequoia #950,000
Toyota picnic #670,000
Toyota Sienna #600,000
Toyota Tacoma #2.7m.
Toyota Tundra #2.5M.
Toyota Venza #1.2M
Toyota Yaris #900,000
Volkswagen Golf 2,3,4 #250,000 /#450,000
Volkswagen Passat #600,000.
Volkswagen Touareg #600,000
Acura MDX #1.3
Acura TL #1M
Acura ZDX #2M
Audi A4 #500,000
Audi A6 #650,000
BMW 3-Series #650,000
BMW 5-Series #980,000
Ford Escape #600,000
Ford Explorer #900,000
Honda Baby Boy #500,000
Honda Accord 03 EOD #860,000
Honda Civic #500,000
Honda Crosstour #1.1M
Honda CR-V #750,000
Hyundai Accent #950,000.
Infiniti FX35 #1M
Infiniti FX45 #1.2M
Land Rover Discovery #3M
Lexus ex 300 #800,000
Lexus Rx330,#900,000
Lexus Rx350,#1.4m
Lexus Rx400, #2m
RANG ROVER SPORT =#2.5M.
Land Rover LR3 #950,000.
MERCEDES BENZ DIFFERENT MODEL.
NOTICE: THE PRICE OF THOSE VEHICLES DEPEND ON THEIR YEAR MODEL.
Bags of cement #3,500
Delivery cost is #1,000